When the Atlanta Thrashers moved to Winnipeg, the NHL was in dire need for a realignment. Winnipeg would have had to stay in the Southeast Division for at least a year giving the southern teams and the Jets a difficult traveling schedule. While they were already planning on switching up the Divisions, the question for the NHL was whether or not they should completely shake up the way the teams are divided.
Well they did.
 |
NHL Division Map Before Realignment. |
After an hour long meeting yesterday with the NHL Board of Governors, the league decided to adopt a system where there are 4 different conferences. The teams were split up for traveling convenience. There are 2 conferences with 8 teams (those two conferences are with Western teams) and then the two 7 team conferences are with Eastern teams. All 30 NHL teams voted whether or not they liked the proposal and an astonishing 26 teams voted yes for it (they required at least 20 teams to vote for it). So the four conferences are:
Western Teams:
Anaheim Ducks, Los Angeles Kings, San Jose' Sharks, Phoenix Coyotes, Colorado Avalanche, Vancouver Canucks, Calgary Flames, and Edmonton Oilers.
Dallas Stars, St. Louis Blues, Chicago Blackhawks, Minnesota Wild, Winnipeg Jets, Nashville Predators, Detroit Red Wings, and Columbus Blue Jackets.
Eastern Teams:
Toronto Maple Leafs, Montreal Canadiens, Ottawa Senators, Buffalo Sabres, Boston Bruins, Florida Panthers, and Tampa Bay Lightning.
New Jersey Devils, New York Rangers, New York Islanders, Washington Capitals, Philadelphia Flyers, Pittsburgh Penguins, and Carolina Hurricanes.
 |
NHL Conference Map After Realignment |
Well here's how the scheduling is going to work. For teams in the 7 team conference, you play each conference team six times and then play a home and home with every other team in the NHL.
Now for the playoffs schedule. The top 4 teams in each conference make the playoffs. Yes that means that if there's a good team in a difficult division and they finish fifth in their conference, they won't make the playoffs while a not-as-good team in a weak conference will. Let's say the Devils have 84 points in their tough conference and finish 5th, a team with 80 pionts may make the playoffs in a weaker conference. And this is definitely something that's going to occur and it WILL agitate many fans.
So the first two rounds are inter-conference games. The 1 seed vs. the 4 seed and the 2 seed vs. the 3 seed. Then the winners of those games meet. That means that there won't be any chance of a rivalry game past the second round. Most rivalry matchups will be wasted within the first two rounds. Great series like the Rangers-Devils or Penguins-Capitals will be done with quickly and we won't see them late in the playoffs. That's one slight thing that's disappointing for the NHL who's had memorable Conference Finals in years past. Another problem is that the 2 best teams in the league might end up playing in the second round if they're in the same division instead of those teams making it deep into the playoffs. That will definitely take away from the excitement of those late rounds.
The NHL has not yet announced its plans for post-second round of the playoffs.
The change obviously has its ups and downs. For starters, they set up the conferences with rivalries in mind so each team will play their rival a good 6 times. We will see Crosby against Ovechkin a lot more than we normally would. Also, we will automatically see rare Eastern team vs. Western teams on a daily basis now. With every team playing each other at least two times a year, we'll see good games like Vancouver against Boston.
Now for some problems with this idea.
The Buffalo Sabres play the Devils, Rangers, and Islanders the same amount of times they play teams like the Ducks or Sharks. This doesn't quite make sense geographically.
Another thing, the Carolina Hurricanes pretty much lost every single rivalry they made. Their only division team they have left with them next year is the Washington Capitals who we all know is A) not much of a rivalry anymore and B) the Caps are sure to move on to new/past rivals like the Islanders or the Penguins.
The change did make several teams happy though with their traveling. These teams were stuck in the Western Conference having to play a lot on the West Coast which was an inconvenience to the team's traveling schedule and the fans' viewing schedule. Those teams included the Detroit Red Wings, Columbus Blue Jackets, Dallas Stars, and Minnesota Wild.
Another inconvenience this change presents is that the Winnipeg Jets only play other Canadian teams twice a year each. These are marquee matchups that aren't going to happen too often after this season.
But there are still some good things about this. The likelihood of seeing those rivalry playoff series are much greater. Year after year we'll be seeing series with the Rangers-Devils, Penguins-Capitals, Oilers-Flames, Bruins-Canadiens etc. That is definitely a good thing for the NHL.
The fact though that 26 out of the 30 NHL teams voted for this was pretty amazing. It shows that most teams are on board with this idea. As for the 4 teams that didn't vote for it? Well analyst Pierre LeBrun hypothesized that among those 4 teams were the Rangers and Lightning. I personally think that the Hurricanes, Lightning, Panthers, and Islanders were the teams.
In my opinion, I think that realignment was necessary; we all did. But I don't think we needed something THIS radical. I don't like the playoff system for previously stated reasons. I kind of like the fact that the regular season means more. There are less playoff spots for bubble teams to make it now. If the Washington Capitals slack off for a part of the season (like they're doing this year) they might not make the playoffs. So this makes regular season games more important. But I also don't like that teams play other teams on the different side of the map as many times as they play teams a few miles away from them. It just doesn't make sense.
A couple of more pressing matters.
Firstly (and most important,) is what are we going to name these conferences? A lot of speculation is going around (including this
great article by Puck Daddy on Yahoo! sports) but nobody knows for sure. Possibilities are the classic Northeast, Atlantic, Pacific, and Central. But the NHL has had divisions like the Patrick, Smythe, or Adams, honouring past players. So people are wondering if there will be more recent legends being honoured (e.g. Gretzky, Orr, Hull, etc.)
Another issue is what will we do with the Wales and Campbell Trophies. Those trophies are presented to the champions of the Eastern and Western Conference respectively. Well now those trophies seem obsolete. But it's not like players touch it anyway...
Note: Please vote on the side of the page for if you like the realignment plans or not.